We all do it. We say this even when we’re not ok. Someone casually asks,
“Hey, how are you?” and we say,
“I’m fine!” and that’s it.
Why do we do this?
To be polite. We don’t want to make the other person feel awkward or embarrassed. Sometimes it’s something people ask how you are as an ice breaker, to get a conversation moving. We believe they aren’t really expecting a detailed response, because they have an ulterior motive for talking to us.
It’s a knee jerk reaction. We say it without even thinking. We’ve said it hundreds of times before and now it’s become second nature. Even if we want to say no, I’m not fine, we’ve said it already and feel like we can’t backtrack.
We feel rushed. Life often feels like it’s rushing by, and our days feel full to the brim. It’s the same with our conversations. Everyone is in such a hurry to get to their point, to say what needs to be said, they don’t stop and take time to really talk. But most importantly, we don’t always feel like we will be listened to.
We’re conditioned to say it. Everyone reacts the same way to the same question. It’s almost seen as improper to reply in any other way. We’ve grown up hearing it. Our parents said it as we were growing up. Our friends say it. Our colleagues say it. We overhear it in public. Because we’ve heard it again and again, by so many different people, there seems like there’s no other reply to make.
All of these reasons are there for one reason only. The F word; Fear
We fear what someone will think if we’re honest. We’re worried about the reaction we’ll get. The stigma attached to feeling unwell mentally means we hide our true feelings. We’re scared that the person who asked the question will not take us seriously, will judge us, will think we’re weak, or simply not care. In that split second these thoughts circle our minds and we answer how we always do.
I don’t want people to feel guilty for saying “I’m fine.” I don’t want mentally unwell people to feel the weight of having to change their behaviour. It’s up to both sides to change the course of the conversation.
Asking how someone is isn’t a simple question. No one is just ‘fine.’ So we shouldn’t expect that answer and should answer that question honestly and openly. I’ve spoken on the blog about self honesty before, which is part of what we need to do to be honest with others.
“Actually I’m not ok.”
“Honestly I’m struggling at the moment.”
“Life’s tough right now.”
When you’re asking how someone is, really mean it. Sit down with them, over a drink or a meal so they feel that you’re present in the conversation. Build up to it. Don’t just blurt out “How are you?” If you’ve noticed a change in them recently start with that.
“I’ve noticed you’ve been quieter recently”
“I’ve been a bit worried about you”
“I thought it would be good to have a catch up.”
Time To Change are running a simple yet powerful campaign encouraging people to ask twice. Asking someone how they are and if they respond with they’re ok, ask them again. It shows you actually want to have a meaningful conversation with them. You’re not rushing them, you’re not waiting for your turn to speak.
Have that conversation, be honest and frank about how you’re feeling. For both sides it will make a difference.
8 thoughts on “The Problem With “I’m Fine!” When Really We’re Not”
Brilliant post x
It is just so easy to say OK or fine. I agree we need to break the habit.
We definitely do, but it’s important that the person asking tries their best to support us.
So true. I try to be honest about how I am feeling although sometimes people are not “really” asking.
I know, it’s tough when people don’t really mean what they say.
Great post 💖